Carbocation rearrangement MCQs With Answer

by

Carbocation rearrangement MCQs With Answer

Carbocation rearrangements are key reaction steps in organic chemistry and are critically important for B.Pharm students studying reaction mechanisms, drug synthesis, and metabolic pathways. This concise, keyword-rich introduction covers carbocation stability, 1,2-hydride and 1,2-alkyl shifts, resonance stabilization, Wagner–Meerwein rearrangements, ring expansions, and relevance to SN1 and acid-catalyzed reactions. Understanding factors like hyperconjugation, inductive effects, and neighboring group participation helps predict product distribution and reaction kinetics. These MCQs focus on mechanism insight, product prediction, stereochemical outcomes, and common pitfalls encountered in exams and practical synthesis. Now let’s test your knowledge with 50 MCQs on this topic.

Q1. Which factor most increases the stability of a carbocation?

  • Presence of an adjacent electron-withdrawing group
  • Resonance delocalization with an adjacent pi system
  • Being primary rather than tertiary
  • Isolation from hyperconjugation

Correct Answer: Resonance delocalization with an adjacent pi system

Q2. A 1,2-hydride shift in a carbocation leads to:

  • Formation of a radical
  • Conversion of a carbocation to a neighboring stabilized carbocation
  • Elimination to form an alkene directly
  • Breaking of a carbon–carbon bond

Correct Answer: Conversion of a carbocation to a neighboring stabilized carbocation

Q3. In SN1 reactions, carbocation rearrangement is most likely when:

  • The leaving group is extremely poor
  • A more stable carbocation can form via a 1,2-shift
  • The substrate is methyl
  • Solvent is completely nonpolar

Correct Answer: A more stable carbocation can form via a 1,2-shift

Q4. Wagner–Meerwein rearrangement typically involves which type of shift?

  • 1,3-hydride shift
  • Electron transfer
  • 1,2-alkyl or hydride shift
  • Direct nucleophilic attack without shift

Correct Answer: 1,2-alkyl or hydride shift

Q5. Which carbocation is most stable?

  • Primary carbocation
  • Secondary carbocation
  • Tertiary carbocation
  • Methyl carbocation

Correct Answer: Tertiary carbocation

Q6. What drives a 1,2-alkyl shift in a carbocation intermediate?

  • Formation of a less substituted carbocation
  • Relief of ring strain or formation of a more stable carbocation
  • Decrease in resonance stabilization
  • Formation of a primary carbocation

Correct Answer: Relief of ring strain or formation of a more stable carbocation

Q7. Which of the following best describes a bridged carbocation rearrangement?

  • Simple hydride removal without migration
  • Migration that opens a bridge to give a more stable carbocation
  • Direct nucleophile attack at the bridgehead atom
  • Formation of a radical intermediate

Correct Answer: Migration that opens a bridge to give a more stable carbocation

Q8. Which experimental observation suggests carbocation rearrangement has occurred during a reaction?

  • Exclusive formation of expected unrearranged product
  • Formation of unexpected isomeric products
  • No change in product distribution with time
  • Complete recovery of starting material

Correct Answer: Formation of unexpected isomeric products

Q9. A resonance-stabilized allylic carbocation will favor which pathway?

  • Rapid 1,2-shift to a less stable center
  • Delocalization without rearrangement due to resonance stabilization
  • Immediate elimination exclusively
  • Formation of a radical cation

Correct Answer: Delocalization without rearrangement due to resonance stabilization

Q10. Which statement about hydride shifts is correct?

  • Hydride shifts always produce less stable carbocations
  • Hydride shifts are 1,3 processes only
  • Hydride shifts transfer an H¯ (hydride) from an adjacent carbon to the carbocation center
  • Hydride shifts require a radical intermediate

Correct Answer: Hydride shifts transfer an H¯ (hydride) from an adjacent carbon to the carbocation center

Q11. In acid-catalyzed dehydration of alcohols, rearrangements occur because:

  • The carbocation intermediate can shift to a more stable position
  • Alkenes cannot form directly
  • Water is a poor leaving group
  • Protonation prevents any migration

Correct Answer: The carbocation intermediate can shift to a more stable position

Q12. Which of the following is least likely to undergo 1,2-alkyl shift?

  • A carbocation adjacent to a tertiary center
  • A benzylic carbocation with resonance stabilization
  • A carbocation trapped by strong nucleophile immediately
  • A carbocation where shift would create significant ring strain

Correct Answer: A carbocation where shift would create significant ring strain

Q13. Neighboring group participation (NGP) can affect carbocation rearrangements by:

  • Completely preventing any stabilization
  • Providing an alternate stabilized intermediate that may avoid simple 1,2-shifts
  • Always causing elimination instead of substitution
  • Converting carbocations into radicals

Correct Answer: Providing an alternate stabilized intermediate that may avoid simple 1,2-shifts

Q14. Which product indicates a 1,2-methyl shift occurred during an SN1 substitution of R-CH(CH3)CH2-LG?

  • R-CH(CH3)CH2-Nu (unrearranged)
  • R-C(CH3)2-CH2-Nu (rearranged)
  • R-CH2-CH(CH3)-Nu with retention
  • R-CH2-CH2-CH3 (simple reduction)

Correct Answer: R-C(CH3)2-CH2-Nu (rearranged)

Q15. Which situation favors rearrangement over immediate nucleophilic capture?

  • Very strong nucleophile present
  • Short-lived carbocation with neighboring stabilization
  • Formation of a significantly more stable carbocation by shift
  • Extremely low temperature

Correct Answer: Formation of a significantly more stable carbocation by shift

Q16. What is the primary driving force for ring expansion via carbocation rearrangement?

  • To increase angle strain
  • To form a less stable carbocation
  • To relieve ring strain and form a more stable carbocation
  • To create more steric hindrance

Correct Answer: To relieve ring strain and form a more stable carbocation

Q17. In bridging systems (bicyclic), carbocation rearrangement can lead to:

  • Only retention of original bridgehead geometry
  • Ring opening to give a more stable open carbocation or rearranged bridgehead
  • Complete prevention of substitution reactions
  • Formation of free radicals exclusively

Correct Answer: Ring opening to give a more stable open carbocation or rearranged bridgehead

Q18. A benzylic carbocation is less likely to rearrange because:

  • It has strong resonance stabilization that reduces the driving force for shift
  • It cannot be attacked by nucleophiles
  • It is always less stable than aliphatic carbocations
  • Hydride shifts to benzylic positions are impossible

Correct Answer: It has strong resonance stabilization that reduces the driving force for shift

Q19. Which experimental parameter can slow down carbocation rearrangement?

  • Increasing temperature dramatically
  • Using a polar protic solvent
  • Adding a very fast nucleophile to trap the carbocation
  • Increasing concentration of substrate

Correct Answer: Adding a very fast nucleophile to trap the carbocation

Q20. During acid-catalyzed hydration of an alkene showing a rearranged alcohol product, the rearrangement occurred at the stage of:

  • Nucleophilic attack on the alkene
  • Formation of the carbocation intermediate
  • Protonation of the alcohol product
  • Final deprotonation step only

Correct Answer: Formation of the carbocation intermediate

Q21. Which shift is most common in simple carbocation rearrangements?

  • 1,5-hydride shift
  • 1,2-hydride shift
  • Direct carbon–carbon bond cleavage without shift
  • Concerted double 1,2-shifts simultaneously

Correct Answer: 1,2-hydride shift

Q22. A tertiary carbocation adjacent to a cyclobutyl ring often undergoes which process?

  • 1,2-hydride shift to a less substituted carbon
  • Ring expansion via migration to relieve ring strain
  • Immediate nucleophilic trapping without rearrangement
  • Formation of a stable primary carbocation

Correct Answer: Ring expansion via migration to relieve ring strain

Q23. Which of the following increases the rate of carbocation rearrangement?

  • Stabilization of the starting carbocation to the same extent as potential product
  • Large energy gain on forming the rearranged carbocation
  • Presence of a very strong nucleophile that competes immediately
  • Low-temperature conditions

Correct Answer: Large energy gain on forming the rearranged carbocation

Q24. In determining whether a hydride or alkyl shift will occur, what is most important?

  • Which bond is weaker in isolation
  • Whether the shift produces a more stabilized carbocation (tertiary, resonance, etc.)
  • Only the steric bulk of migrating group
  • The color of the reaction mixture

Correct Answer: Whether the shift produces a more stabilized carbocation (tertiary, resonance, etc.)

Q25. Which of these carbocations is most resonance-stabilized?

  • Carbocation adjacent to a nitro group
  • Benzylic carbocation
  • Simple tertiary alkyl carbocation with no pi system
  • Methyl carbocation

Correct Answer: Benzylic carbocation

Q26. Which describes a situation where rearrangement is kinetically favored?

  • When rearrangement has a lower activation energy than nucleophilic capture
  • When nucleophilic attack is instantaneous
  • When the rearranged product is thermodynamically less stable
  • When solvent completely stabilizes the original carbocation only

Correct Answer: When rearrangement has a lower activation energy than nucleophilic capture

Q27. In the mechanism of pinacol rearrangement, what key species forms and rearranges?

  • Carbanion intermediate
  • Oxonium or carbocation species after protonation and water loss
  • Free radical cation
  • Stable alkene intermediate with no charge

Correct Answer: Oxonium or carbocation species after protonation and water loss

Q28. Which migrating group generally migrates fastest in a 1,2-shift?

  • Hydride
  • Phenyl group
  • Fluorine atom
  • Carboxylate anion

Correct Answer: Hydride

Q29. A secondary carbocation next to a quaternary carbon may rearrange to:

  • Form a less substituted carbocation
  • Form a tertiary carbocation by a 1,2-alkyl shift
  • Always undergo elimination only
  • Convert into an anion

Correct Answer: Form a tertiary carbocation by a 1,2-alkyl shift

Q30. Which of the following best describes why aryl shifts (migration of an aryl group) are less common?

  • Aryl groups are too small to migrate
  • Migrating an aryl group often requires disruption of aromaticity or higher activation energy
  • Aryl shifts are forbidden by orbital symmetry
  • Aryl groups cannot stabilize carbocations

Correct Answer: Migrating an aryl group often requires disruption of aromaticity or higher activation energy

Q31. Which reagent choice would decrease the chance of carbocation rearrangement during substitution?

  • Use of a weak, slow nucleophile in polar protic solvent
  • Use of a very strong, fast nucleophile under SN2-favoring conditions
  • Elevated temperature to lengthen carbocation lifetime
  • Highly stabilizing solvent for carbocations

Correct Answer: Use of a very strong, fast nucleophile under SN2-favoring conditions

Q32. In terpene biosynthesis, carbocation rearrangements are important because they:

  • Prevent formation of complex skeletons
  • Enable formation of diverse carbon frameworks via cascade rearrangements
  • Always lead to aromatization
  • Only produce linear products

Correct Answer: Enable formation of diverse carbon frameworks via cascade rearrangements

Q33. Which description fits a non-classical carbocation?

  • A localized positive charge on a single carbon
  • A delocalized bridged structure where positive charge is shared over multiple atoms
  • A fully aromatic cation with no positive center
  • An anionic resonance form

Correct Answer: A delocalized bridged structure where positive charge is shared over multiple atoms

Q34. Stereochemical outcome after a carbocation intermediate is captured by a nucleophile is often:

  • Exclusive retention of configuration
  • Complete inversion always
  • A racemic or partially racemic mixture due to planar carbocation
  • Formation of only one enantiomer because carbocations are chiral

Correct Answer: A racemic or partially racemic mixture due to planar carbocation

Q35. In which case will a 1,2-shift not occur even if it could form a more stable carbocation?

  • When migration would break an aromatic system or severely destabilize the molecule
  • When solvent is polar and stabilizes charges
  • When temperature is high
  • When the starting carbocation is very unstable

Correct Answer: When migration would break an aromatic system or severely destabilize the molecule

Q36. Which product distribution strongly suggests a reversible carbocation equilibration before capture?

  • Only unrearranged product
  • A mixture of products weighted toward the thermodynamically most stable product
  • Products formed exclusively by kinetic control with no rearranged species
  • No product formation

Correct Answer: A mixture of products weighted toward the thermodynamically most stable product

Q37. Which technique can provide evidence for transient carbocations in a reaction?

  • NMR trapping experiments or low-temperature spectroscopic observation
  • X-ray crystallography of the intermediate in solution
  • Thin-layer chromatography only
  • Simple boiling point measurement

Correct Answer: NMR trapping experiments or low-temperature spectroscopic observation

Q38. A methyl shift that converts a secondary carbocation into a tertiary one is an example of:

  • 1,2-alkyl shift
  • 1,3-hydride shift
  • Radical rearrangement
  • Elimination

Correct Answer: 1,2-alkyl shift

Q39. Which of the following best explains why tertiary carbocations are more stable than secondary?

  • Greater resonance delocalization
  • More hyperconjugation and inductive donation from adjacent alkyl groups
  • Tertiary centers always form bonds with oxygen
  • Tertiary carbocations are smaller in size

Correct Answer: More hyperconjugation and inductive donation from adjacent alkyl groups

Q40. In electrophilic addition to alkenes, rearrangement after initial attack occurs if:

  • The initial carbocation intermediate can rearrange to a more stable carbocation
  • The alkene is symmetric and gives only one product
  • There is no possibility to form a better-stabilized carbocation
  • The reaction is concerted with no intermediates

Correct Answer: The initial carbocation intermediate can rearrange to a more stable carbocation

Q41. Which migrating aptitude order is generally correct for 1,2-shifts?

  • Phenyl > hydride > alkyl
  • Hydride > alkyl > phenyl in many contexts due to lower barrier for hydride
  • Alkyl always migrates faster than hydride
  • Halogens migrate fastest

Correct Answer: Hydride > alkyl > phenyl in many contexts due to lower barrier for hydride

Q42. Rearrangement that leads to a resonance-stabilized carbocation is often:

  • Unfavorable because resonance reduces stability
  • Highly favorable and common
  • Impossible in aromatic systems
  • Only observed under radical conditions

Correct Answer: Highly favorable and common

Q43. Which of the following is true about carbocation lifetimes and rearrangement?

  • Short-lived carbocations always rearrange
  • Longer-lived carbocations have more time to rearrange or equilibrate
  • Lifetime does not affect rearrangement probability
  • Carbocations with infinite lifetime never rearrange

Correct Answer: Longer-lived carbocations have more time to rearrange or equilibrate

Q44. In the solvolysis of 2-bromo-3-methylbutane, a major rearranged product indicates:

  • No carbocation formed
  • Carbocation intermediate underwent 1,2-shift before nucleophilic capture
  • SN2 mechanism exclusively
  • Elimination without substitution

Correct Answer: Carbocation intermediate underwent 1,2-shift before nucleophilic capture

Q45. Which structural feature reduces the likelihood of carbocation rearrangement?

  • Presence of adjacent tertiary carbon
  • Strong resonance stabilization of the initial carbocation
  • Ability to form a more stable carbocation by migration
  • Bridgehead positions that can open easily

Correct Answer: Strong resonance stabilization of the initial carbocation

Q46. Which is a real-world relevance of understanding carbocation rearrangements for B.Pharm students?

  • Designing inert materials only
  • Predicting metabolites and reaction outcomes in drug synthesis and degradation
  • Irrelevant to pharmacology
  • Only useful for inorganic synthesis

Correct Answer: Predicting metabolites and reaction outcomes in drug synthesis and degradation

Q47. Which rearrangement would you expect in the acid-catalyzed ring opening of norbornyl derivatives?

  • No rearrangement due to extreme stability
  • Non-classical bridged cation formation and possible rearrangement
  • Only radical pathways
  • Exclusive SN2 substitution without intermediates

Correct Answer: Non-classical bridged cation formation and possible rearrangement

Q48. How does a solvent that stabilizes carbocations affect rearrangement?

  • It always prevents rearrangement
  • It can increase the lifetime of the carbocation, allowing more rearrangement
  • It converts carbocations into carbanions
  • It forces immediate elimination

Correct Answer: It can increase the lifetime of the carbocation, allowing more rearrangement

Q49. During biosynthetic terpene cyclizations, multiple sequential carbocation rearrangements occur because:

  • Enzymes prevent any cation formation
  • Carbocation cascades generate complex stereochemistry and carbon frameworks efficiently
  • Only single-step reactions are allowed in biological systems
  • Rearrangements are avoided to maintain structure

Correct Answer: Carbocation cascades generate complex stereochemistry and carbon frameworks efficiently

Q50. Which analytical result would most directly indicate that a methyl shift occurred during a synthetic transformation?

  • IR spectrum showing same functional groups but different connectivity confirmed by NMR shifts and coupling patterns
  • Unchanged physical properties
  • Color change only
  • No need for spectroscopic confirmation

Correct Answer: IR spectrum showing same functional groups but different connectivity confirmed by NMR shifts and coupling patterns

Leave a Comment