Carbocation rearrangement (SN1) MCQs With Answer

Carbocation rearrangement (SN1) MCQs With Answer

Understanding carbocation rearrangements during SN1 reactions is crucial for B.Pharm students studying reaction mechanisms and drug synthesis. This concise, keyword-rich introduction covers carbocation stability, hydride and alkyl shifts, resonance and hyperconjugation effects, neighboring group participation, solvent influence, and product distribution in nucleophilic substitution (SN1). Knowing how and why carbocations rearrange helps predict major products, stereochemistry, and reaction kinetics—essential for medicinal chemistry and formulation. These MCQs focus on mechanism details, energy profiles, and common laboratory observations to deepen your conceptual and applied knowledge. Now let’s test your knowledge with 50 MCQs on this topic.

Q1. Which factor most directly stabilizes a tertiary carbocation formed during an SN1 reaction?

• Inductive effect from electron-withdrawing groups
• Hyperconjugation from adjacent C–H bonds
• Decrease in solvent polarity
• Steric hindrance around the leaving group

Correct Answer: Hyperconjugation from adjacent C–H bonds

Q2. Which rearrangement commonly occurs when a secondary carbocation can become a more stable tertiary carbocation?

• Beta-elimination
• Hydride shift
• Radical recombination
• SN2 backside attack

Correct Answer: Hydride shift

Q3. What is the main driving force for alkyl shifts in carbocation rearrangements?

• Formation of a more stable, lower-energy carbocation
• Formation of a free radical intermediate
• Increase in entropy due to more molecules
• Direct nucleophilic attack before rearrangement

Correct Answer: Formation of a more stable, lower-energy carbocation

Q4. In an SN1 reaction, if rearrangement occurs, when does it typically take place?

• Before leaving group departs
• Simultaneously with nucleophilic attack
• After formation of the carbocation intermediate but before nucleophilic capture
• Only during product isolation

Correct Answer: After formation of the carbocation intermediate but before nucleophilic capture

Q5. Which statement about resonance-stabilized carbocations (allylic or benzylic) in SN1 reactions is true?

• They never undergo rearrangement
• They are more stable and form more readily than non-resonance carbocations
• They always lead to racemic mixtures
• They favor SN2 over SN1

Correct Answer: They are more stable and form more readily than non-resonance carbocations

Q6. Which effect decreases carbocation stability?

• Electron-donating alkyl groups
• Resonance delocalization
• Electron-withdrawing substituents
• Hyperconjugation

Correct Answer: Electron-withdrawing substituents

Q7. The Hammond postulate helps explain transition state resemblance. For an endothermic carbocation formation step in SN1, the transition state resembles:

• The reactants more than the products
• The products more than the reactants
• An intermediate radical
• A concerted SN2 transition state

Correct Answer: The products more than the reactants

Q8. Neighboring group participation can alter carbocation behavior. Which group often participates to stabilize a neighboring carbocation?

• Methyl group via sigma donation
• A lone-pair containing atom like oxygen or sulfur
• A distant aromatic ring with no conjugation
• A purely inductive electron-withdrawing substituent

Correct Answer: A lone-pair containing atom like oxygen or sulfur

Q9. What stereochemical outcome is typically observed in SN1 reactions without neighboring group participation?

• Complete retention of configuration
• Complete inversion of configuration
• Racemization or partial racemization
• No change because the configuration is irrelevant

Correct Answer: Racemization or partial racemization

Q10. Which solvent property favors SN1 reactions and promotes carbocation formation?

• Low dielectric constant and non-polar
• High polarity and ability to stabilize ions
• Strong nucleophilicity of the solvent
• High viscosity

Correct Answer: High polarity and ability to stabilize ions

Q11. Which experimental observation indicates carbocation rearrangement has occurred?

• Formation of only the expected substitution product with no isomers
• Isolation of products with altered carbon skeletons or positional isomers
• No reaction under polar protic solvent conditions
• Exclusive formation of enantiopure product

Correct Answer: Isolation of products with altered carbon skeletons or positional isomers

Q12. In a bridged bicyclic system, carbocation formation sometimes leads to ring expansion. Which process accounts for this?

• Hydride abstraction by radical
• Alkyl shift or ring expansion to form a more stable carbocation
• Concerted SN2 displacement
• Elimination to form an external alkene

Correct Answer: Alkyl shift or ring expansion to form a more stable carbocation

Q13. Which of the following best describes a non-classical carbocation?

• A carbocation with a localized positive charge on a single carbon
• A delocalized cation where positive charge is shared over a bridged framework
• A radical cation formed by one-electron oxidation
• A stable carbanion intermediate

Correct Answer: A delocalized cation where positive charge is shared over a bridged framework

Q14. During an SN1 reaction of 2-bromo-3-methylbutane, which rearrangement is most probable?

• Benzyl shift
• Hydride shift from adjacent carbon yielding a tertiary carbocation
• Concerted methyl transfer to nucleophile
• No rearrangement due to resonance stabilization

Correct Answer: Hydride shift from adjacent carbon yielding a tertiary carbocation

Q15. Which technique can experimentally demonstrate a hydride shift in an SN1 mechanism?

• NMR spectroscopy with deuterium labeling
• Melting point determination
• UV-Vis spectroscopy of starting material
• Gravimetric analysis of product mass

Correct Answer: NMR spectroscopy with deuterium labeling

Q16. If a carbocation intermediate is resonance-stabilized, how does this affect the rate of SN1 reaction?

• Rate decreases due to steric hindrance
• Rate increases because carbocation formation is easier
• Rate becomes zero because resonance prevents reaction
• Rate is unchanged

Correct Answer: Rate increases because carbocation formation is easier

Q17. In the context of SN1, what is the role of a leaving group?

• To donate electrons to stabilize the nucleophile
• To depart and generate the carbocation intermediate
• To act as the nucleophile attacking the substrate
• To increase solvent polarity

Correct Answer: To depart and generate the carbocation intermediate

Q18. Which substituent on an adjacent carbon would most likely accelerate carbocation rearrangement?

• Strong electron-withdrawing nitro group at beta-position
• Multiple adjacent methyl groups enabling hyperconjugation
• Bulky tert-butyl group far from carbocation center
• Fluorine via negative inductive effect

Correct Answer: Multiple adjacent methyl groups enabling hyperconjugation

Q19. During SN1 of 3° alcohol with acid, what intermediate is commonly formed before carbocation?

• Neutral alkoxide
• Protonated alcohol (oxonium), then water leaves to give carbocation
• Radical cation
• Carbanion stabilized by solvent

Correct Answer: Protonated alcohol (oxonium), then water leaves to give carbocation

Q20. Which observed product ratio suggests fast rearrangement relative to nucleophilic attack?

• Predominantly unrearranged substitution product
• Significant proportion of rearranged substitution product
• Only elimination products
• No reaction observed

Correct Answer: Significant proportion of rearranged substitution product

Q21. In SN1 reactions, what effect does increasing temperature often have on rearrangement versus substitution?

• Favors substitution exclusively
• May favor elimination (E1) competing with rearrangement and substitution
• Prevents carbocation formation
• Eliminates any stereochemical changes

Correct Answer: May favor elimination (E1) competing with rearrangement and substitution

Q22. What is hyperconjugation?

• Delocalization of electrons through overlapping p-orbitals in conjugated systems
• Stabilization of carbocations by donation from adjacent C–H sigma bonds
• Transfer of hydride to solvent molecules
• Formation of a sigma bond between nucleophile and electrophile

Correct Answer: Stabilization of carbocations by donation from adjacent C–H sigma bonds

Q23. Which of the following best predicts whether a hydride shift will occur?

• Whether the nucleophile is strong or weak
• Whether the shift leads to a more substituted (more stable) carbocation
• The boiling point of the solvent
• The presence of radical initiators

Correct Answer: Whether the shift leads to a more substituted (more stable) carbocation

Q24. Which is a common consequence of carbocation rearrangement in pharmaceutical synthesis?

• Unchanged regioselectivity of reaction
• Formation of unexpected isomeric impurities affecting purity
• Guaranteed formation of only the desired product
• Elimination of need for purification

Correct Answer: Formation of unexpected isomeric impurities affecting purity

Q25. For the solvolysis of tert-butyl chloride in water (SN1), what is the major carbocation-stabilizing interaction?

• Hydrogen bonding to the chloride ion
• Hyperconjugation from three methyl groups
• Pi-stacking interactions with water
• Formation of a radical pair

Correct Answer: Hyperconjugation from three methyl groups

Q26. Which scenario would least likely show carbocation rearrangement?

• Formation of a primary carbocation without resonance stabilization
• Formation of a secondary carbocation adjacent to tertiary center
• Formation of a benzylic carbocation
• Formation of a tertiary carbocation

Correct Answer: Formation of a primary carbocation without resonance stabilization

Q27. What distinguishes SN1 from SN2 in terms of mechanism relevant to rearrangements?

• SN1 proceeds via a concerted single-step displacement
• SN1 forms a discrete carbocation intermediate that can rearrange; SN2 does not
• SN2 intermediates always rearrange
• SN1 is impossible in polar protic solvents

Correct Answer: SN1 forms a discrete carbocation intermediate that can rearrange; SN2 does not

Q28. Which observation supports that neighboring group participation influenced SN1 stereochemistry?

• Complete racemization
• Predominant formation of one stereoisomer due to bridged intermediate
• No reaction occurs
• Equal amounts of starting material and product

Correct Answer: Predominant formation of one stereoisomer due to bridged intermediate

Q29. How does a good leaving group affect the rate of SN1?

• Slows it down by stabilizing reactant
• Accelerates it by facilitating carbocation formation
• Prevents nucleophile from approaching
• Has no effect

Correct Answer: Accelerates it by facilitating carbocation formation

Q30. Which of the following is most likely when a carbocation intermediate is formed next to an aromatic ring with electron-donating substituents?

• Destabilization of carbocation and slower SN1
• Enhanced stabilization via resonance and faster SN1
• Immediate elimination without substitution
• Formation of a carbanion

Correct Answer: Enhanced stabilization via resonance and faster SN1

Q31. In an SN1 reaction where a methyl shift yields a more stable carbocation, what moves during the shift?

• A hydrogen atom only
• A methyl group (with its bonding electrons) from an adjacent carbon to the carbocation center
• An electron from solvent to form radical
• A proton that forms H2 gas

Correct Answer: A methyl group (with its bonding electrons) from an adjacent carbon to the carbocation center

Q32. Which energy diagram feature indicates a rate-determining carbocation formation step in SN1?

• A single low-energy barrier followed by no intermediates
• A high first activation energy to form carbocation followed by lower barrier for nucleophilic attack
• A higher barrier for nucleophilic attack than for ionization
• No transition state visible

Correct Answer: A high first activation energy to form carbocation followed by lower barrier for nucleophilic attack

Q33. Which type of shift can lead to ring contraction or expansion during carbocation rearrangement?

• Alpha-elimination
• Alkyl shift involving migration of a ring bond
• Direct nucleophilic substitution at the leaving group
• Photochemical cleavage of C–H bonds

Correct Answer: Alkyl shift involving migration of a ring bond

Q34. How would you experimentally distinguish SN1 with rearrangement from a concerted pericyclic rearrangement?

• Measure reaction kinetics and look for first-order dependence indicative of SN1 carbocation formation
• Assume rearrangement mechanism from product color
• Only mass spectrometry can tell the difference
• There is no way to distinguish

Correct Answer: Measure reaction kinetics and look for first-order dependence indicative of SN1 carbocation formation

Q35. In solvolysis, a faster rate in a more polar solvent indicates what about the transition state?

• It is less polar than reactants
• It is more polar and stabilized by the solvent, consistent with charge separation
• It does not involve charge separation
• It is a radical transition state

Correct Answer: It is more polar and stabilized by the solvent, consistent with charge separation

Q36. Which carbocation would be most stabilized by resonance?

• A primary carbocation adjacent to a phenyl ring
• A primary carbocation with no adjacent pi system
• A tertiary carbocation with no resonance
• A methyl carbocation

Correct Answer: A primary carbocation adjacent to a phenyl ring

Q37. What is the effect of nucleophile strength on the extent of rearrangement in SN1?

• Stronger nucleophiles always prevent rearrangement
• Weak nucleophiles favor longer-lived carbocations, increasing chance of rearrangement
• Nucleophile strength has no effect
• Stronger nucleophiles increase rearrangement by abstraction of hydride

Correct Answer: Weak nucleophiles favor longer-lived carbocations, increasing chance of rearrangement

Q38. Why might a bridgehead carbocation be less likely to form and rearrange?

• Bridgehead carbocations are generally highly stabilized
• Bridgehead positions often cannot achieve the required planar sp2 geometry, making stable carbocation formation difficult
• They always undergo immediate nucleophilic substitution without intermediate
• They are readily formed and never rearrange

Correct Answer: Bridgehead positions often cannot achieve the required planar sp2 geometry, making stable carbocation formation difficult

Q39. In SN1, what is “anchimeric assistance”?

• Assistance by solvent only
• Participation of a neighboring group (often with a lone pair) that stabilizes carbocation via internal bonding
• Assistance by added acid catalysts exclusively
• Stabilization by ionic salts in solution

Correct Answer: Participation of a neighboring group (often with a lone pair) that stabilizes carbocation via internal bonding

Q40. Which isotope labeling experiment helps track hydride shifts?

• 13C labeling at remote positions
• Deuterium (2H) labeling at potential migrating hydrogen sites
• Using 18O labeled water
• Incorporating 14C into the solvent

Correct Answer: Deuterium (2H) labeling at potential migrating hydrogen sites

Q41. What is the expected outcome when a benzylic carbocation forms during SN1?

• Rapid rearrangement to a non-aromatic carbocation
• Strong stabilization by resonance leading to fast reaction without major skeletal rearrangement
• Immediate polymerization
• Complete inhibition of nucleophilic attack

Correct Answer: Strong stabilization by resonance leading to fast reaction without major skeletal rearrangement

Q42. Which describes a concerted SN1-like process with neighboring group participation?

• Two-step process with a long-lived carbocation
• A concerted displacement where neighboring group forms a bridged ion, reducing free carbocation lifetime
• Pure SN2 with inversion only
• Thermal pericyclic rearrangement

Correct Answer: A concerted displacement where neighboring group forms a bridged ion, reducing free carbocation lifetime

Q43. How does substitution pattern affect the relative rate of SN1 for alkyl halides?

• Primary > Secondary > Tertiary
• Tertiary > Secondary > Primary
• All have equal rates
• Only primary undergo SN1

Correct Answer: Tertiary > Secondary > Primary

Q44. Which product outcome suggests that a methyl shift occurred during solvolysis?

• Product retains original carbon skeleton with only substitution at leaving group carbon
• Product shows substituent located at adjacent carbon where methyl migration could lead to a new tertiary center
• No product formation
• Exclusive elimination product with no substitution

Correct Answer: Product shows substituent located at adjacent carbon where methyl migration could lead to a new tertiary center

Q45. Which factor will NOT favor carbocation formation?

• Polar protic solvent
• Good leaving group
• Strong electron-withdrawing groups adjacent to carbocation site
• Heating the reaction mixture

Correct Answer: Strong electron-withdrawing groups adjacent to carbocation site

Q46. In pharmaceutical synthesis, why is understanding carbocation rearrangement important?

• It helps predict side-product formation and ensures correct regioselectivity of active molecules
• It is only academically interesting with no practical implications
• It guarantees 100% yield of desired product
• It prevents the need for purification methods

Correct Answer: It helps predict side-product formation and ensures correct regioselectivity of active molecules

Q47. What does an SN1 reaction rate law typically look like?

• Rate = k[substrate][nucleophile]
• Rate = k[substrate]
• Rate = k[substrate]^2
• Rate independent of substrate concentration

Correct Answer: Rate = k[substrate]

Q48. Which carbocation rearrangement might occur to relieve ring strain?

• Hydride shift only
• Ring expansion via bond migration (alkyl shift)
• Photochemical sigma bond cleavage exclusively
• Nucleophilic substitution at a distant center

Correct Answer: Ring expansion via bond migration (alkyl shift)

Q49. When a carbocation intermediate is short-lived due to fast nucleophilic attack, what is the expected extent of rearrangement?

• High extent of rearrangement producing many isomers
• Low extent of rearrangement with mainly unrearranged product
• Complete decomposition to radicals
• Exclusive formation of polymeric byproducts

Correct Answer: Low extent of rearrangement with mainly unrearranged product

Q50. In designing a synthesis to avoid unwanted rearrangement, which strategy is useful?

• Use conditions that make the carbocation long-lived
• Choose a substrate that forms a highly stable carbocation
• Use alternative pathways such as SN2 or protect potential migrating groups
• Increase reaction temperature dramatically

Correct Answer: Use alternative pathways such as SN2 or protect potential migrating groups

Download